Table of contents
Get insights delivered straight into your inbox every week!

Dedicated IP vs Shared IP: What's the difference?

Choosing between a dedicated IP and a shared IP isn’t just a technical decision — it’s a pipeline decision. 

Deliverability, speed, reputation, even compliance — it all ties back to your IP setup.

In 2025, this choice is harder than ever. 

Email volume is exploding. 

Spam filters are smarter. 

IP reputation can make or break your outreach. If you care about growth, you need to get this right.

This guide breaks it all down — no jargon, just what actually matters.

What’s an IP Address (And Why You Should Actually Care)

An IP (Internet Protocol) address is your digital identity.

It's how the internet recognizes your emails, servers, devices—basically, anything you're sending or hosting online.

Example: typing “64.233.187.99” loads Google.com. That’s how it works behind the scenes.

There are two main versions:

  • IPv4 – The OG format (e.g., 192.168.0.1). But it's running out—only 4.3 billion total exist.

  • IPv6 – A 128-bit system (e.g., 2001:db8::8a2e:370:7334) offering virtually unlimited addresses. 

By early 2025, global IPv6 adoption is over 43%, with countries like France (80%), Germany (75%), and India (74%) leading, while the U.S. lags at just over 50% 

Here’s why this matters:
 

As more systems go IPv6-first, your provider’s infrastructure will directly affect your scalability and deliverability.

How IPs Are Assigned

Internet Service Providers (ISPs) and Regional Internet Registries (RIRs) assign IP addresses. 

The Domain Name System (DNS) translates user-friendly domain names (e.g., google.com) into IP addresses, simplifying access. 

Mailforge automates DNS setup for shared IPs, making them user-friendly.

Let’s break down how dedicated and shared IPs actually stack up.

Dedicated IP vs Shared IP: What’s the Real Difference?

What is a Dedicated IP?

A dedicated IP is yours alone. Think of it like your own phone number.

You control everything that happens with it, and only your actions impact the results. 

Infraforge uses dedicated IPs to guarantee inbox placement for serious senders.

What is a Shared IP?

A shared IP is used by multiple users at the same time. It’s like a group email line.

It’s cheaper, and it works—if the provider keeps the pool clean. 

Mailforge does this well by rotating high-reputation IPs between vetted users.

Here’s a quick side-by-side:

Aspect Dedicated IP Shared IP
Definition Exclusive to one user Shared by many
Control Full control Limited, provider-led
Reputation Yours to manage Affects and is affected by others
Cost $1–$5/month Often included in tools

At a glance:

  • Dedicated IP = more power, more responsibility

  • Shared IP = easier, cheaper, but shared outcomes

Let’s break down what each setup gives you.

Pros & Cons of Dedicated IPs

✅ Pros ⚠️ Cons
Full control over your sender reputation Requires manual warmup and monitoring
Strong deliverability for high-volume senders Higher cost ($1–$5/month + setup time)
Easier to whitelist for secure and compliant environments Risk of blacklisting if mismanaged
Consistent speed and performance, especially under heavy traffic Technical effort required to keep it healthy
Ideal for companies needing tight security or regulatory compliance Not recommended for new senders or low-volume outreach

Infraforge helps automate warmup and monitoring so you’re not buried in technical maintenance — but make no mistake, you’re in charge.

Pros & Cons of Shared IPs

✅ Pros ⚠️ Cons
Low cost—often included in email/hosting platforms Reputation is shared—bad actors can drag down your deliverability
Pre-warmed pools boost early inbox placement Less control over sender performance and reputation
Easy to set up—DNS and IP management handled by a provider Not ideal for high-volume or regulated use cases
Great for new or low-volume senders Performance may dip if the pool gets overloaded
Managed by providers like Mailforge to ensure healthy rotation Limited customization for advanced security or routing needs
Note: Mailforge protects against this by vetting users, managing the pool daily, and rotating clean IPs across campaigns. That’s why it’s trusted by lean teams scaling cold email without the tech headache.

Still not sure which one’s right for you? Let’s map it to real-world use cases.

Use Cases: Which IP Setup Wins Where?

📘 Scenario ✅ Use Dedicated IP If... 🤝 Use Shared IP If...
Cold Emailing You send 100K+ emails/year You send <10K/month or are just starting
Hosting You need security, compliance, or isolation You’re running a standard site
VPN/Remote Access You want static, secure access You need privacy and geo access
Marketing Campaigns You need precision and deliverability control You want to test fast, cheap

Now let’s talk about performance — where speed, stability, and security really separate these two.

Security, Speed & Scale: How IP Choice Impacts All 3

🔐 Feature ✅ Dedicated IP 🤝 Shared IP
Security High (whitelisting, compliance-ready) Moderate (depends on pool hygiene)
Speed Consistent Can be slow if overloaded
Scalability Great for growth Best for lean, steady use

What It’ll Cost (And What It’ll Cost If You Get It Wrong)

Dedicated IPs:

  • $1–$5/month
  • Time investment: warmup, maintenance, monitoring

Shared IPs:

  • Often free or included
  • Risk: reputation drag if the pool isn’t clean

What’s the hidden cost?

Bad deliverability = lost revenue.

Your emails never hit the inbox? Doesn’t matter how good your copy is.

The future of IPs is evolving rapidly.

Future Trends in IP Addressing

Where It's Headed

  • IPv6 is the Future

    43 %+ global adoption means more available IPs, making dedicated IPs cheaper and easier to get.

  • Smarter Shared Pools

    Top providers are cleaning up IP pools with automation, rotation, and user vetting for better reliability.

What It Means for You

  • Startups:

    Shared IPs stay budget-friendly and fast to deploy, especially with tools like Mailforge.

  • Enterprises:

    More teams are shifting to dedicated IPs for control, compliance, and performance. Infraforge is built for that.

What’s Driving It?

IoT, 5G, and growing demand for secure, static IPs—all made scalable by IPv6.

Common Myths

  • Myth: Shared IPs hurt SEO

    Not true. Google cares about content, not your IP.

  • Myth: SSL needs a dedicated IP

    Nope. SNI handles SSL across shared IPs just fine.

  • Myth: Shared IPs aren’t safe

    Quality providers vet users and rotate IPs to keep pools clean.

Conclusion

Dedicated IPs give you control, security, and performance—perfect if you send high-volume email, need strong hosting, or operate in a regulated space.

Shared IPs offer speed, simplicity, and low cost—ideal for startups, solo marketers, or teams just getting started.

IPv6 makes both options better. But your choice comes down to control, risk tolerance, and what you’re trying to scale.

Quick Recap:

  • Email: Dedicated for high-volume pros, shared for lean teams.

  • Hosting: Dedicated for compliance, shared for most sites.

  • VPNs: Dedicated for static access, shared for flexibility.

Mailforge simplifies shared IP outreach with no warmup or maintenance. Try Mailforge for free now!

Infraforge gives power users full control with automated warmup, blacklist monitoring, and a dedicated lane. Try Infraforge for free!

Pick the setup that matches your growth stage—and scale with confidence.